I first encountered Merchants of the Dark Road at a small convention in Minneapolis—the same city where my board game journey began all those years ago with Settlers of Catan. It was tucked away at a demo table in the back corner, the box art catching my eye with its moody blues and the warm glow of lantern light. The demonstrator, a bearded fellow with enthusiasm that could power a small city, described it as “a pick-up-and-deliver game with a twist—eternal darkness.” Twenty minutes into his explanation, I was mentally rearranging my schedule to make sure I got a full play in before the convention ended.
The game didn’t make it into my collection until about eight months later. Linda had instituted her infamous “one-in-one-out policy” for shelf space, and I wasn’t quite ready to part with anything. Then my birthday rolled around, and there it was—wrapped in paper covered with little meeples that my daughter had drawn by hand. My family knows me well. By midnight, we’d played our first full game, with me fumbling through rule explanations while trying not to sound too excited about lantern mechanics and caravan optimization.
After 27 plays (yes, I keep a log—don’t judge me), I’ve developed some approaches to caravan planning that consistently yield good results. Not that winning is everything, but understanding the game’s underlying systems makes for more satisfying play experiences all around. At least that’s what I tell my son when he groans as I break out the spreadsheet I use to track different strategies.
The central challenge in Merchants of the Dark Road is navigating the risk-reward balance of traveling through a kingdom shrouded in perpetual darkness. It’s like planning a road trip where every highway has broken streetlights and the gas stations might randomly close—except with more fantasy elements and fewer restroom breaks. Though sometimes the tension of a particularly risky journey does make bathroom visits more urgent. Just saying.
Let’s start with what I consider the foundation of successful merchant journeys: lantern management. New players often underestimate the importance of those little light tokens, treating them as a secondary resource rather than the game’s lifeblood. In my first few games, I repeatedly found myself stranded in darkness, watching helplessly as other merchants zoomed past with their well-lit caravans. It was during our fifth game, while stuck between two cities with an empty lantern and valuable goods I couldn’t deliver, that the importance of light planning finally clicked.
I’ve since developed what my gaming group calls “Mitchell’s Illumination Rule”—never, under any circumstances, end your planning phase without calculating your exact lantern needs for the journey plus a two-token buffer. That buffer has saved me more times than I can count, especially when unexpected events force route changes or when another player snatches the last available lantern-refill action just before your turn. Kevin from my Tuesday group still brings up the time I lectured everyone about lantern buffers right before ignoring my own advice and ending up stranded. He’s never going to let me live that down.
Route planning in Merchants is equally crucial and considerably more complex than in most pick-up-and-deliver games. The shifting demand for goods creates a constantly evolving puzzle that rewards flexibility as much as foresight. I track successful delivery patterns across games (Linda calls this “excessive” but I prefer “thorough”) and have found that the most profitable routes aren’t necessarily the longest ones—they’re the ones that align most closely with current market demands while minimizing unnecessary lantern usage.
In a particularly memorable game last winter, I secured a narrow victory by focusing exclusively on short, high-demand deliveries while my opponents committed to longer journeys. They covered more ground and made fewer total deliveries, but my targeted approach yielded higher per-delivery profits and conserved precious lantern light. The looks on their faces when I revealed my final score was priceless—a mixture of surprise and grudging respect, followed quickly by demands to examine my delivery tokens to ensure I wasn’t cheating. I wasn’t, for the record. My victories are always legitimate, if occasionally perplexing to those who haven’t yet grasped the mathematical beauty of optimized trade routes.
The caravan upgrade system introduces another layer of strategic consideration. Those upgrade slots aren’t just nice bonuses—they’re essential tools for crafting a coherent merchant strategy. I’ve observed three distinct approaches to caravan development that yield consistently strong results: the Lantern Conservationist (focusing on upgrades that reduce light consumption), the Cargo Master (maximizing goods capacity and flexibility), and the Swift Trader (emphasizing movement efficiency and action advantages).
My personal preference leans toward a hybrid of the Lantern Conservationist and Cargo Master approaches. By reducing light requirements while increasing carrying capacity, you create a caravan that can make multiple deliveries on a single journey without constantly worrying about running out of light. My son, conversely, swears by the Swift Trader approach, zipping around the board with fewer goods but completing deliveries at a blistering pace. Our head-to-head games have been surprisingly close, suggesting multiple viable paths to merchant success—one of the hallmarks of excellent game design, in my opinion.
Reputation management represents yet another crucial aspect of Merchants of the Dark Road that new players often overlook. Those reputation points aren’t just victory points—they’re a resource that opens up strategic options throughout the game. In our third play, I discovered the power of early reputation building when I gained access to a particularly valuable noble delivery that none of my opponents could fulfill. That single delivery provided both substantial points and a caravan upgrade that shaped my strategy for the remainder of the game.
Since then, I’ve made reputation a priority in the early game, sometimes even accepting less profitable deliveries specifically for the reputation boost. This approach creates a positive feedback loop: more reputation leads to better delivery opportunities, which in turn generate more reputation. It’s like building good credit—boring at first, but incredibly valuable once established. The parallels to financial planning are not lost on Jim from accounting, who always points them out at length. Thanks, Jim.
The noble patron system adds a fascinating wrinkle to delivery prioritization. Those distinguished passengers aren’t just fancy victory point packages—they’re strategic tools that can dramatically alter your merchant’s capabilities. I’ve found that selecting nobles whose abilities complement your caravan’s strengths while offsetting its weaknesses yields the best results. In one game, I paired a noble who provided additional light with my cargo-focused caravan to create a delivery powerhouse that could transport massive quantities of goods across long distances without light concerns.
Timing your market activities represents another subtle but significant aspect of merchant strategy. The fluctuating values of different goods create opportunities for savvy traders who can anticipate market shifts. I’ve developed a habit of studying the market board at the beginning of each round, identifying goods likely to increase in value, and adjusting my collection and delivery plans accordingly. This approach occasionally requires passing on immediate delivery opportunities in favor of holding goods for future rounds when their value increases—a counterintuitive strategy that has nonetheless secured several narrow victories.
Weather effects introduce an element of randomness that can frustrate careful planning, but I’ve found that treating weather as an opportunity rather than an obstacle often yields surprising benefits. When heavy snow slows movement, I pivot to shorter routes with higher-value goods. When clear skies boost travel speeds, I adjust to longer deliveries that maximize the favorable conditions. The key is adaptability—rigid adherence to a single strategy regardless of conditions is the surest path to mercantile failure.
The interaction between players adds another layer of complexity to caravan planning. Unlike some pick-up-and-deliver games where players operate in relative isolation, Merchants creates numerous opportunities for both hindrance and indirect cooperation. Watching other merchants’ collection patterns provides valuable intelligence about potential market shifts and delivery opportunities. In a game last month, I noticed Linda focusing heavily on luxury goods, signaling their likely increased value in future rounds. I adjusted my own collection strategy accordingly and managed to capitalize on the price spike just before she could bring her goods to market. The look she gave me suggested I might be making my own dinner for the next week. Worth it, though.
If I could distill my approach to Merchants of the Dark Road into a single principle, it would be this: successful merchants think in complete journeys, not individual actions. Each decision—from goods collection to route planning to upgrade selection—should serve a coherent strategy that maximizes efficiency across entire delivery cycles. A seemingly suboptimal action can be the right choice if it sets up a highly profitable sequence in subsequent turns.
During our family vacation last summer, we brought Merchants along (it fits perfectly in a suitcase if you remove the insert, though Linda insists this level of game transport planning is “concerning”). After several vacation plays, my teenage daughter captured this principle perfectly when she said, “It’s like chess—you’re not playing for this move, you’re playing for three moves ahead.” She proceeded to demolish us all with a brilliantly executed delivery chain that none of us saw coming. I’ve never been prouder, or more thoroughly defeated.
The rhythm of Merchants of the Dark Road creates distinct phases across the game’s arc. Early rounds typically focus on establishing your mercantile infrastructure—securing key upgrades, building initial reputation, and testing different delivery patterns. Mid-game turns toward efficiency optimization—refining routes, aligning with market demands, and accumulating resources for major delivery chains. The end-game often becomes a race to capitalize on final scoring opportunities while managing increasingly scarce resources.
Understanding this rhythm helps inform strategic pivots at crucial junctures. In a recent game that came down to the final turn, I abandoned my carefully cultivated delivery chain to make a single high-value noble delivery that secured just enough points for victory. Had I stubbornly stuck to my original plan, I would have finished a distant third. Sometimes the best-laid caravan routes must be abandoned when a better opportunity emerges from the darkness.
Merchants of the Dark Road continues to hit our table regularly despite the ever-growing collection threatening to collapse our shelves. There’s something uniquely satisfying about planning the perfect journey through perpetual darkness, navigating both physical and economic obstacles to emerge as the kingdom’s premier merchant. Plus, I’m still convinced there’s an optimal caravan configuration I haven’t quite discovered yet. Maybe after another dozen plays, I’ll find it. Linda just sighed audibly when I said that out loud. She knows me too well.
Leave a Reply